Birth* | circa 1859 | She was born circa 1859 at New YorkG.1 |
| 7 July 1860 | She appeared on the census of 7 July 1860 in the household of Morris G Phelps and Cornelia Amelia Patterson at Lyme, Jefferson Co., New YorkG, as Hattie, age 1, b. NY.2 |
| 25 June 1870 | She appeared on the census of 25 June 1870 in the household of Morris G Phelps and Cornelia Amelia Patterson at Three Mile Bay P. O., Lyme Town, Jefferson Co., New YorkG, age 11, b. NY.3 |
| 8 June 1880 | She appeared on the census of 8 June 1880 in the household of Morris G Phelps and Cornelia Amelia Patterson at Chaumont Village, Lyme Town, Jefferson Co., New YorkG, as Hattie, age 20, b. NY, servant.4 |