Birth* | circa 1857 | He was born circa 1857 at New JerseyG.1 |
| 8 August 1860 | He appeared on the census of 8 August 1860 in the household of William Johnson and Deborah Luffburrow at Riceville, Middletown Twp., Monmouth Co., New JerseyG.2 |
| 23 June 1870 | He appeared on the census of 23 June 1870 in the household of William Johnson and Deborah Luffburrow at 16th Ward, New York, Manhattan, New YorkG.3 |
| 9 June 1880 | He appeared on the census of 9 June 1880 in the household of William Johnson and Deborah Luffburrow at 346 W. 24th Street, New York, Manhattan, New YorkG, age 23, b. NJ, produce merchant.4 |