Birth* | circa 1859 | He was born circa 1859 at New YorkG.1 |
| 18 July 1860 | He appeared on the census of 18 July 1860 in the household of Le Ray D Horton and Jane Reynolds, age 1, b. NY; Neis. Stephen and Maria Fisher, fam. 1069; W S and Caroline Horton, fam. 1058.)3 |
| 20 July 1870 | He appeared on the census of 20 July 1870 in the household of William Dare Horton and Louisa Border at Chaumont, Lyme Town, Jefferson Co., New YorkG; (neis. Eben and Lucinda Fisher.)4 |
| 2 June 1875 | He appeared on the census of 2 June 1875 in the household of Angeline Cook Horton, as Fred A, age 16, b. Jefferson Co. NY, laborer; (neis. Eben and Lucinda Fisher, fam. 21.)5 |