| | Her married name was Bates (poss., poor legibility in 1875 census.) |
Birth* | circa 1853 | She was born circa 1853 at New York, New York.1 |
| 16 June 1865 | She appeared on the census of 16 June 1865 in the household of Robert Irving at 13th Ward, New York, Brooklyn Bor., Kings Co., New YorkG.2 |
| 1 June 1870 | She appeared on the census of 1 June 1870 in the household of Robert Irving and Margaret _____, age 16, b. NY.3 |
Marriage* | circa 1871 | She married Anthony Bates circa 1871.4 |
| 22 June 1875 | She appeared on the census of 22 June 1875 in the household of Robert Irving and Margaret _____ at 13th Ward, New York, Brooklyn Bor., Kings Co., New YorkG.5 |